Cafe Cimino Country Inn
616 Main Street
Sutton, West Virginia, 26601, United States
(877) 924-6466 | (304) 765-2913
(304) 765-3664

Café Cimino Country Inn Menu

Restaurant's Hours: Tuesday - Saturday, 4pm-9pm


                                      Brushettas - with Fresh Tomatoes & Basil

or Fresh sautéed Spinach and Fontinella Cheese   12

Olive Plate - a sampling of the chef’s favorite assorted marinated olives

from Italy & Greece   12

Mussels Italiano - Steamed mussels in the chef’s white wine & tomato broth    15

Calabrian Shrimp Cocktail - Shrimp marinated in white wine, lemon, capers, onion, olives, and peppers    15

Caprese Salad - tomatoes & fresh mozzarella with fresh basil, drizzled with

extra virgin olive oil    14

House Roasted Red Pepper with Firefly Farms Goat Cheese Chevre    12

                         Fried Smelt ~ Italian favorite with a spicy remoulade    16


 Chef's Creamy Italian Mushroom Soup     10




Cimino Garden Salad - a fresh garden salad with your choice of House Dressings      8

  • CaesarSalad

Caesar Salad - romaine, Parmigiano-Reggiano, croutons, anchovies, roasted garlic dressing       12

Pasta Entrées

  Olive Oil, Garlic and Basil Pasta or House-Made Basil Pesto Pasta   13

  • meatballs

Cafe Cimino Pasta - linguine tossed with the Cimino Family red sauce    13

                                add Cimino Family 4 oz. Meatballs to any pasta   5.00 each


Sun Dried Tomatoes, Feta, Garlic, Pine Nuts & Fresh Basil- tossed in pasta     22

Creamy Mushrooms & Feta - pasta with sauteed mushrooms in a creamy white Marsala wine sauce      21


Main Course Entrees

Ribeye ~ 16oz chef cut steak, onion, and our seasonal sides   38

Shrimp Scampi - shrimp sauteed in extra virgin olive oil, garlic, butter, sliced mushrooms, and white wine, tossed in pasta     35

  • Pescatore

Shellfish Pescatore - The chef’s signature platter of shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels & calamari in a white wine & tomato seafood broth    65

Chicken San Marino- grilled free range chicken breast stuffed with Fontina cheese & Prosciutto Ham served with a creamy white mushroom Marsala sauce over penne pasta or with seasonal sides   29

  • scallops

Sea Scallops and Prosciutto - Pan-seared scallops wrapped in Prosciutto ham served over pasta with marinara, garlic & extra virgin olive oil or seasonal sides   35

  • filetMignongorgonzola

Filet Mignon Gorgonzola - Chef’s Cut 8oz. Black Angus Prime Beef served with potatoes, and fresh spinach sautéed in olive oil & garlic, creamy Gorgonzola cheese sauce & seasonal sides   55

Bon Appetito!

Our Desserts Vary from day to day… your server will be happy to share today’s dessert specials

We are a proud leader in offering farm-raised, locally grown, organic & artisan-made foods and believe strongly in supporting sustainable agriculture in West Virginia & the Appalachian Region

Café Cimino Country Inn received the 2011 American Culinary Federation’s Achievement of Excellence Award-one of only 23 properties in the US to be recognized for excellence in cuisine & hospitality

Café Cimino Country Inn was the winner of the 2011 WV Division of Tourism Mountain State Award for the highest level excellence in hospitality in the state of WV

Tim & Melody Urbanic, chef/owners were honored by the WV Division of Tourism with the 2011 WV Tourism Professional of the Year Award

2012 winner of West Virginia Cast Iron Cook-Off award for “best representation of Appalachian Cuisine”

Past winner of West Virginia Cast Iron Cook-Off awards:  “Best Use of Locally Grown Produce” given by Department of Agriculture Commissioner, Gus Douglass , of Best Dessert, and Best use of Value Added WV Food Products


Please note that menu offerings & prices may vary based on season and availability

20% service gratuity will be added to all overnight guests’checks, parties of 8 or more & parties over 4 requesting separate checks

Please enjoy the original West Virginia art for sale. Just ask for a price list

…and don’t forget to ask about our Leaf & Bean Cigar Shop & Tapas Tuesday!

616 Main Street, Sutton, WV ~ 1-877-924-6466 or 304-765-2913 ~